26 June 1988 - Air France 296Q The newly delivered A.320 was to perform for Air Charter a series of flights on behalf of the Mulhouse Flying Club. The crew were a.o. to overfly Mulhouse-Habsheim airport two times (first at low speed, gear down at 100ft and the other at high speed in clean configuration) as part of an airshow. The aircraft took off from Basle-Mulhouse at 14.41h and climbed to 1000ft agl. The crew started the descent three minutes later and Habsheim was in sight at 450ft agl. The first officer informed the captain that the aircraft was reaching 100ft at 14.45:14. The descent continued to 50ft 8 seconds later and further to 30-35ft. Go-around power was added at 14.45:35). The A.320 continued and touched trees at the end of the runway at 14.45:40 with a 14deg pitch attitude and engine speed being 83% N1. The plane sank slowly into the forest and a fire broke out. PROBABLE CAUSES: "The Commission believes that the accident resulted from the combination of the following conditions: 1) very low flyover height, lower than surrounding obstacles; 2) speed very slow and reducing to reach maximum possible angle of attack; 3) engine speed at flight idle; 4) late application of go-around power. This combination led to impact of the aircraft with the trees. The Commission believes that if the descent below 100ft was not deliberate, it may have resulted from failure to take proper account of the visual and aural information intended to give the height of the aircraft."
Special note: The FDR was out of control of the authorities for 10 days following this accident. The FDR that was finally produced for examination had been opened, and the white markings on the outside of the case did not match the markings found on a photograph of a man carrying the 2 “black boxes” at the accident scene. >>> LINK <<<
Time: Source: Contents: 12.44:27 TOWER QNH Habsheim 1012 Fox Echo 9.8.4 Captain OK 12.44:31 Co-pilot Roger 12.44:32 Captain 9.8.4 put in 9.8.4 12.44:34 Co-pilot 9.8.4 QFE selected! 12.44:37 Good gear is down; flaps 2! 12.44:42 Captain Flaps 3 12.44:45 Co-pilot Flaps 3! Captain That's the airfield, you confirm? 12.44:48 Co-pilot Affirmative 12.44:51 Co-pilot You see it LL 01, when we get there you're at 1 nautical mile, that's right. 12.44:55 [GONG!] - nosewheel valve 12.45:04.7 GPWS [Too Low Terrain!] Co-pilot OK! 12.45:19.1 Radio altimeter [Forty] 12.45:04.7 [GONG!] - GPWS cut off 12.45:05.7 Radio altimeter [Two hundred] 12.45.11 Co-pilot P.....G.....! (name of flight safety officer) 12.45:11.4 Radio altimeter [Two hundred] 12.45.12 Co-pilot G.. is going to ...eh! 12.45:14 Co-pilot OK, you're at 100ft there, watch, watch 12.45:13 Radio altimeter [One hundred] 12.45:19.1 Radio altimeter [Forty] 12.45:23.6 Radio altimeter [Fifty] 12.45:26 Captain OK ,I'm OK there, disconnect autothrottle 12.45:27.5 Radio altimeter [Forty] 12.45:32 Co-pilot Watch out for those pylons ahaead, eh. See them? 12.45:33 Co-pilot Yeah, yeah, don't worry. 12.45:34.5 [Clack! Clack! Clack!] - power lever dentents 12.45:35.3 Radio altimeter [Thirty] 12.45:36.2 Radio altimeter [Thirty] 12.45:37 Co-pilot TOGA/SRS 12.45:38.3 Radio altimeter [Thirty] 12.45:39 Captain Go around track 12.45:39.9 Captain Sh...! 12.45:41.5 END OF TAPE ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cockpit Voice Recorder Database, visit us at www.tailstrike.com